Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Obama Facebook poll and Washington Post rules


The disturbing news of a
poll on Facebook asking if President Obama "should be killed" points out the real questions around social media best practices and ethics. A developer created the poll, which was taken by more than 700 users. Choices in the poll were Yes, Maybe, If He Cuts My Health Care, and No. The results are not available, Facebook says, and the poll has been taken down and is being probed by the Secret Service.

Organizations like ESPN and, most recently, The Washington Post, have been busy composing restrictions on how employees use social media. It's understandable that organizations want to provide guidelines for employees and draw boundaries for how social media differentiates from their own mainstream media. (In the eyes of The Washington Post, staffers should post to social media as if their bylines were attached. I disagree.)

Since when have communications professionals been more concerned with covering their backsides than with using new tools to serve their audiences, report on the bad guys -- like creepy poll developers -- and provide ethical and laudable communications in the new forums? Preventative measures will fail against social media -- that river of free-flowing information is too strong for any dam. But real best practices, which use these tools for good, can ride the flow of that river. We need to provide good information, not focus on what might go wrong.

Some of the earliest and most crafty users of social media have been doing some of the worst stuff. The Obama poll isn't an isolated incident on Facebook (although it may be the worst). There are four polls that ask Which Serial Killer Are You? There are spam bots and sex bots and phony accounts and crooked apps. The problem isn't Facebook and Twitter. The same old hate and avarice have found new playgrounds. Fear and outrage that blame the messenger are, as always, missing the point.

The best way to address wrongdoing is to do right. The real ethical obligation of media companies is to provide good information, otherwise the creeps lead the way.

Corporations -- especially media outlets -- need to get beyond their fear of getting caught with a goofy tweet and start leading by example. We need to be proactive in communicating with ethics, not preventative in censoring employees. Expose the bad guys, report in new ways, and show the world how this new media can be used right.

The real best practices are not "how to protect my company." We need a Society For Social Media Ethics that covers more than one industry.

Rules that show how journalists or PR people should behave, and focus on what they shouldn't do, are missing the point. We need something that shows how all users can best use Facebook and Twitter and the rest, and media are the best people to provide that.

Communications people need to look beyond what media should not do, and start leading by example in a new way.

17 comments:

  1. I am still not sure why anyone needs "social media" in the first place?

    Is there just simply not to much information overload already?

    ReplyDelete
  2. So, it was OK for someone to make a movie about the assassination of George W. Bush, but it's not OK to have a poll about the assassination of Barack Obama on Facebook?

    Methinks someone's hypocrisy is showing.

    ReplyDelete
  3. with the way republicans and their "voice boxes" (Beck, Rush, Hannity, etc) are stirring the kool-aid drinkers with lies and exaggerations, no i don't think it's a good idea to have a poll about the assassination of our president.
    One day, one of the looneys is gonna do something stupid.

    ReplyDelete
  4. To Anonymous @ 10:07...

    No, it is not ok for someone to either make a movie about the assassination of George W. Bush or create a "Should Obama Be Killed" poll on Facebook. As much as I disliked Bush, he was our President and therefore due the respect of the office. Nothing is settled by alluding to being violently disagreeable. Hypocrisy is not the point my friend.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It was never OK for anyone to make a film about the assination of GW Bush. The film was not made in the USA and was widely condemned by both left and right in this country. The Facebook poll was heinous and no right thinking American would think otherwise.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The real problem here is not FB, Twitter and other social sites; but rather society in a whole. Our Nation is slipping fast from where our Framers started from. Scary times for our children and grandchildren.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was outraged when people called President Bush a Nazi and wistfully talked of him being assassinated. I couldn't imagine that there were people that actually thought that way. Now, seeing the same things said of President Obama, I am beginning to realize that stupidity is ubiquitous. So frankly, I'm not really sure that these sorts of initiatives are really worthwhile. Maybe the healthiest approach is to just not say these things yourself, and accept that a certain percentage of the population is determined to be this way. And when they do say things like that, pat them on the head, smile, and tell them Jesus loves them. Then walk away.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yeahhh. I'm not sure I totally agree with you.

    Although "social networking" has been around for a little while, it's still a relatively new media outlet. To safeguard one's integrity, I think it IS important to pull back the reigns on what one lets fly over the internet. It's not like gossiping to one person which later could be dismissed as hearsay or a misunderstanding.

    Yes, it would be great if WaPo and others were to "lead by example." Laying out the expectations for their journalists can pave the way for this to happen.

    ReplyDelete
  9. 10:07:

    #1: Who said it was ok to make the George Bush assassination movie? Did Jeff say that or any of the other commentors? Oh, some psycho on tv said that? Ok gotcha.

    #2: Methinks? Is it 1350 or 2009? It was bad grammar even in Chaucer's day.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The Obama poll and the assassination movie are both deplorable.

    If organizations/companies are so concerned about how their employees use social media, then why do they have their own facebook groups?

    ReplyDelete
  11. Freedom of speech!!

    s

    and republicans are evil stupid people!!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Anyone that even "inquires" about the williful killing of another person is a sick puppy! Either they *were* joking - but I can't see anyone calling this much of a laughing matter - or else they were SERIOUS! - and that's a criminal offense, especially since we're talking about the President of the United States!

    Disgusting, repulsive, reprehensible. Thoughtless. Whoever posted this "poll" on Facebook gets whatever punishment that gets handed down.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I hope all these Right-Wing WIERDOS get arrested by the FBI and thrown under the Jail....

    ReplyDelete
  14. "I hope all these Right-Wing WIERDOS get arrested by the FBI and thrown under the Jail...."

    With all the left-wing WIERDOS down there I hope there is room :)

    ReplyDelete
  15. In the last 40 years the far right in this country has a much higher rate of violence and murder. This poll and the lame defense of by some is a fine example of how radicalized the right has become.

    Who's more likely to kill someone in church? A "prolife" "Christian." Try and wrap your brain around that.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Busy week for "right and wrong" in social media...

    The Obama poll thing is weird, creepy, scary, and unfortunately, a reflection of our society. As much as we want to marginalize violence-advocating cretins, in reality there's an uncomfortably large number of those folks on either side of the political aisle.

    But moving on...

    I'm hearing more buzz around the topic of corporate/organizational social media policies. Companies of all sizes are wrestling with this.

    Some policies are rigid do/don't rules. Some are loose guidelines. Some are simply extensions of existing employee policies. Some are too narrowly focused on specific technologies, and some focus too much on marketing/PR and overlook other uses.

    And many convey fear.

    I think social media policies/guidelines are a good thing, if crafted carefully. Done well, they can encourage innovation, collaboration and problem-solving while helping employees understand the impact on the company of their behavior online.

    ReplyDelete